SUMMARY: The Jamaica Bay, Marine Park, Plumb Beach Feasibility Study was initiated in 1996 and was subsequently integrated into the Hudson Raritan Estuary (HRE) Feasibility Study in 2014. The feasibility phase has been completed and resulted in the HRE Comprehensive Restoration Plan (CRP) (Volume 1- 2016) which was adopted by the NY/NJ Harbor Estuary Program serving as the blueprint and master plan for restoration with partners in the region. The Final HRE Feasibility Report and Environmental Assessment (FR/EA) (April 2020) and Chief’s Report (May 2020) recommended the construction of 20 individual restoration projects, including five (5) marsh island sites (Stony Creek, Duck Point, Pumpkin Patch East and West, Elders Center), Dead Horse Bay, Fresh Creek, and oyster restoration at the Head of Jamaica Bay. The HRE Recommended Plan will restore a mosaic of 621 acres of habitat that will reduce long-term and large-scale degradation in the HRE. These projects were authorized for construction in the Water Resource Development Act (WRDA) of 2020 for a total first cost of $420,473,000 and fully funded cost (escalated to mid-point of construction) of $598,042,000 (FY21 Price Level). The Pre-Construction Engineering and Design (PED) Phase of each project will be initiated pending appropriations. Funding of $1.2M ($300,000 each) for the first 4 projects (Stony Creek Marsh Island, Bronx Zoo & Dam/Stone Mill Dam (combined), Flushing Creek and Oysters at Naval Weapons Station Earle and) was included in the FY22 Senate Mark-up Bill. The New York District and New York City Department of Environmental Protection (NYCDEP) will execute a Design Agreement for the Stony Creek Marsh Island restoration project upon receipt of funds.
See the project placemat on the web link below for the specific restoration projects and habitats and engineering designs for each site. All documents can be found at: https://www.nan.usace.army.mil/Missions/Environmental/Environmental-Restoration/Hudson-Raritan-Estuary/.
DESCRIPTION: The Hudson Raritan Estuary (HRE) is within the boundaries of the Port District of New York and New Jersey and is situated within a 25-mile radius of the Statue of Liberty National Monument. The HRE feasibility study area includes 8 Planning Regions: 1) Jamaica Bay; 2) Lower Bay; 3) Lower Raritan River; 4) Arthur Kill/Kill Van Kull; 5) Newark Bay, Hackensack River and Passaic River; 6) Lower Hudson River; 7) Harlem River, East River, and Western Long Island Sound; and 8) Upper Bay. The Jamaica Bay, Marine Park and Plumb Beach Feasibility Study Area is located within the Jamaica Bay HRE Planning Region.
The HRE and Jamaica Bay feasibility studies’ purpose was to identify and document water resource related problems, existing conditions and factors contributing to environmental degradation within the estuary and specifically the Jamaica Bay in order to develop potential solutions aimed at ecosystem restoration. The overall objectives of both studies were to restore ecological function and diversity that have been lost or degraded as a result of human activities.
The USACE and multiple non-federal sponsors commenced HRE, the Jamaica Bay, Marine Park and Plumb Beach and four (4) other concurrent ecosystem restoration feasibility studies in the 1990s and early 2000s that focused on the restoration of different areas of the HRE. In an effort to streamline parallel efforts, and maximize efficiencies, resources and benefits, the feasibility studies were integrated into the HRE Feasibility Study effort between 2013 and 2015. The HRE Feasibility Report and Environmental Assessment (FR/EA) fulfills the authorizations of all six (6) feasibility studies.
Implementation of the HRE Ecosystem Restoration Feasibility Study’s recommendations will enable the USACE, its non-Federal cost-sharing sponsors, and other regional stakeholders to restore and protect lost or degraded aquatic, wetland and terrestrial habitats within the HRE study area. These activities will be accomplished by implementing various site-specific ecosystem restoration projects formulated within the context of an overall strategic plan.
Jamaica Bay, Marine Park, Plumb Beach- Committee on Public Works and Transportation of the United States House of Representatives Resolution dated August 1, 1990.
HRE- House of Representatives Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure Resolution dated April 15, 1999, Docket Number 2596.
STATUS: Federal interest was determined to address shore protection, storm damage reduction, hurricane protection and environmental restoration objectives during the Reconnaissance phase in 1994. A Feasibility Cost Share Agreement was executed with New York City Department of Environmental Protection (NYCDEP) for ecosystem restoration in 1996. During the early stages of the feasibility study, significant data collection (including water quality/modeling, cultural resource surveys, topographic/bathymetry, hazardous toxicity radioactive waste [HTRW] sampling, water levels/tide gauges, biological communities, evaluation of planned wetlands, bio-benchmarks, hydrodynamic modeling) and planning efforts were conducted in coordination with the National Parks Service between 2001 and 2004. Based on this data and partner coordination, a total of 44 restoration opportunities were identified and evaluated, resulting in the recommendation of eight (8) perimeter (shoreline) sites, along the periphery of Jamaica Bay, as the tentatively selected plan (TSP) in 2010. Meanwhile, initial steps to address the vanishing marsh islands were advanced using the USACE Continuing Authorities Program (CAP). A preliminary draft integrated feasibility report and environmental assessment was prepared in 2010 but was never finalized.
Following Hurricane Sandy, which severely impacted portions of New York and New Jersey in October 2012, the perimeter sites were evaluated further in the East Rockaway to Rockaway Inlet and Jamaica Bay Reformulation Study as potential natural/nature-based features. Recommendations for ecosystem restoration within the Jamaica Bay Study Area, also the Jamaica Bay Planning Region, were integrated into the HRE Feasibility Study in 2014.
In parallel, the USACE identified a need for a strategic plan as a first step of the HRE Feasibility Study. With participation of the regional stakeholders, the USACE and the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey developed a Comprehensive Restoration Plan (CRP) that now serves as the master plan and blueprint for future restoration within the HRE region. The CRP provides the framework for an estuary-wide ecological restoration program by utilizing restoration targets -Target Ecosystem Characteristics (TECs) established through a collaborative effort among the region’s stakeholders in 2005 through 2007. The CRP Program goal was to develop a mosaic of habitats that provide society with renewed and increased benefits from the estuary environment. Each TEC is an important ecosystem property or feature that is of ecological and/or societal value including restoration of coastal wetlands, shellfish/oyster reefs, eelgrass beds, waterbird islands, public access, maritime forest, tributary connections, shorelines and shallow habitat, fish crab and lobster habitat, reduction of contaminated sediments and improvement of enclosed and confined waters. The CRP provides a strategic plan to achieve the TEC goals, identify potential restoration opportunities and mechanisms for implementation. The Draft CRP was released in April 2009 and was adopted by the New York/New Jersey Harbor Estuary Program (HEP) as the path forward for restoration in the future. Following intensive public outreach, CRP Version 1.0 was released in June 2016.
The HRE Feasibility Study recommended specific restoration projects throughout the HRE Study Area, including Jamaica Bay, that advance the CRP goals and provide solutions for water resource problems. Feasibility activities included the evaluation of a subset of priority CRP sites including ecological functional assessments, preparation of restoration alternatives, engineering designs and cost estimates, National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) Environmental Assessments and Cost Effectiveness/Incremental Cost Analysis (CE/ICA) for each site. In addition, other restoration opportunities outlined in the CRP were recommended for further feasibility study investigation which would require subsequent Congressional construction authorization. A total of 33 sites were recommended as the Tentatively Selected Plan (TSP) in the Draft Integrated FR/EA released for public review in February 2017 following the TSP Milestone accomplished in August 2016.
The District had coordinated with the Vertical Team to address policy comments and completed additional tasks to confirm the TSP and ensure policy compliance (tasks included update of costs, ecological benefits, relative sea level change analysis and Planning Region CE/ICA evaluations). Following completion of these tasks, the Agency Decision Milestone (ADM) was held on September 5, 2018 and four (4) Jamaica Bay sites (Hawtree Point, Dubos Point, Brant Point and Bayswater State Park) were removed from further consideration.
Final feasibility level activities were completed for the remaining sites and the Final Integrated Feasibility Report and Environmental Assessment was submitted to HQUSACE on 11 February 2020 for review and approval. The State and Agency review occurred March 16, 2020 through April 15, 2020. The Chief’s Report was signed by LT General Todd Semonite on 26 May 2020 and was authorized for construction by Congress in the Water Resource Development Act (WRDA) of 2020 in December.
The Recommended Plan includes restoration at 20 individual project locations including five (5) marsh island sites (Stony Creek, Duck Point, Pumpkin Patch East and West, Elders Center), Dead Horse Bay, Fresh Creek, and oyster restoration at the Head of Jamaica Bay. The HRE Recommended Plan will restore a mosaic of 621 acres of habitat that will reduce long-term and large-scale degradation in the Hudson Raritan Estuary for a total first cost of $420,473,000 and fully funded cost (escalated to mid-point of construction) of $598,042,000 (FY21 Price Level).
The recommended plan includes:
• Restoration of approximately 381 acres of estuarine wetland habitat (including six miles of tidal channels), 50 acres of freshwater riverine wetland habitat, 27 acres of coastal and maritime forest habitat, 39 acres of shallow water habitat and 52 acres of oyster habitat.
• Two fish ladders would be installed and three weirs would be modified to re-introduce or expand fish passage (24 miles) and control flow rate and water volume along the Bronx River.
• A total of 1.6 miles of stream bank and 72 acres of stream bed and channel would be restored.
Jamaica Bay, Marine Park and Plumb Beach
Federal: $ 2,405,311
Ms. Lisa Baron
P: (917) 790-8306 and C: (646) 385-1429
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, New York District
Programs and Project Management Division, Civil Works Programs Branch
NY U.S. Sen. Charles E. Schumer
NY U.S. Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand
NY-05 Rep. Gregory Meeks
NY-08 Rep. Hakeem Jeffries
NY-09 Rep. Yvette Clarke